written by Melanie Naumann
I'm a fan of My Chemical Romance for many reasons, but primarily because I love how they use the power of storytelling in their lyrics.
And, of course, the music is what my heart and soul love to hear.
And, on Friday the 13th, 2022, they dropped a new song – after eight years – finally a new song: 'The Foundations of Decay'!
I was so excited! I started listening to the song right away.
It started so well! The music contributed to my expectations even before I heard the first words.
Their new song promised an incredible listening experience — the mood setting was great, building up to the moment they introduced one of the main characters with the song's first line.
And that first line invited me into the story:
"See the man who stands upon the hill
He dreams of all the battles won"
I was soooo curious to learn more about that man.
I immediately thought back to 'The Patient' from their third album, The Black Parade – another broken soul, and I wondered how he'd deal with his specific challenge.
So the first verse and pre-chorus continue, giving me a clear picture of the song's main character, his main problem, and how much he struggles.
And I'm so intrigued to learn more about his circumstances, and what led to the all-is-lost moment he's facing now.
And then the chorus sets in, and GUESS WHAT?!?
The music overshadowed the vocals.
It was too loud and made it so damn hard to understand a single word.
And I felt frustrated and lost.
I couldn't follow along anymore, which made me feel left out.
With every passing line that I couldn't understand, I knew I was missing so much from the story. I hated that!
The music stifled the singing.
And if this hadn't been my favorite band, I would have just skipped to the next song.
I was invested in the story, engaged and interested, and then cut off.
After the song ended, I just sat there with a broken image and not enough puzzle pieces to understand what that song was about.
You can have the best-written lyrics in the entire world, but if your music battles against the vocals and tunes them out, then your audience will get frustrated!
They want to enjoy the music and follow along with what is being said.
And if they can't, they'll feel frustrated, just like I did.
Control the volume of the music and instruments.
Even if you know the words of the lyrics and can make them out in all the 'noise', ask someone who hasn't heard your song before to tell you what is being sung.
This approach might avoid setting 'The Foundations of Decay' for your audience.
Note: And yes, even when you're writing a song and you know some lines are not that good... and you consider playing the music louder so no one will 'hear' those 'bad' lines... yes, that will disrupt your audience's experience and bump them out.
So don't do it! Just write better lines.
Never ever use the volume to make up for the things you could have done better from the start.
The best way to improve is by getting feedback!
If you want to be confident in your lyrics before you record your song, you can now sign up below to get constructive, actionable feedback on your song lyrics. So you know what works and how you can do better so that you can hook, move, and impact your audience with your words.
Get Your FREE Copy.
So you can grab your listener's attention with your song's first line!
Discover the Power of Storytelling in Songwriting
Subscribe to my YouTube Channel for lyric breakdowns, songwriting tips, tutorials, discography studies, and songwriter battles 🥊.
Thanks for reading,
Melanie.
Stop Second-Guessing Your Lyrics
Get Real Feedback That Moves You Forward
Click below to get constructive, actionable feedback on your song lyrics. So you know what works and how you can do better so that you can hook, move, and impact your audience with your words.
Leave a Comment
NEWSLETTER
Get your FREE Copy
How to Write Opening Lines That Make Your Song Stand Out in Seconds