The Fatal Mistake That Will Stop Your Song From Making an Impact


written by Melanie Naumann

Why you should STOP writing songs like this.

So what do I mean by STOP writing songs like this?


Here's an example of what a song can sound like that seems impactful, but that will not make an impact:

(Verse 1)

In the silence of the night, I search for peace

Trying to mend what's torn, to find release

Feels like I'm chasing shadows, lost in space

Caught in a never-ending race


(Chorus)

Do you ever feel the weight of the same old game?

Seeking truth but everything seems just the same

I hold onto this prayer, it's my saving grace

I'm sending it to you in this sacred space


(Verse 2)

When you stumble and fall, can you hear the call?

Echoes of love, breaking through the walls

In the darkest hours, when all seems lost

Remember the stars, count the ones you've crossed


(Chorus)


(Bridge)

In the wreckage of our dreams, we find our strength

Piecing together what's left, we go to any length

Through the storms and the rain, we'll find our way

Guided by the light, leading us to a brighter day


(Chorus)

The lines sound nice. The flow seems okay. It all seems to fit together nicely.


And still... it's just abstract fluff.


Just like:

The lyrics are too abstract.


Of course, they carry a meaningful message. It sounds great. It's something positive. Something we want to believe in.


But there's no anchor for those words, no foundation, and no story.


We don't have any idea ...

  • who those two characters in that song are,
  • nor do we know their relationship with each other.
  • We don't even know if that song is about love, life, personal growth, ...
  • We don't know what the song's main character's situation looks like
  • We don't know the place or the time
  • We don't know what the real problem is that they're struggling with
  • We don't know how they came to that revelation (how can it help someone when we don't even know how they got to the place where they are now?)
  • ... and the list goes on and on

There are so many pieces that do not allow the listener to discover the CONTEXT of what the song is all about.


So how will the listener know to which life situation they can apply those words if they don't have a reference point?


Yes, the lyrics may sound nice.


But impact, there's none.


Because the lyrics are too abstract, too general, ... there's no specificity.


There's nothing vulnerable being shared.


And there's nothing that would allow the listener to relate to the song's main character... because they don't even know WHO those people are.


So, how can the listener build an emotional connection to the song's world when there is none?

And we need that emotional connection so the song's message can "bypass the audience's critical minds to touch their hearts, and change their worldviews!"

And there's no journey the song's main character embarks on to solve the problem they're struggling with.


And when there's no journey, the song doesn't offer an experience for the audience.


So all they are left with are some words that sound good, and they know there's some truth to it... but they can't do anything with what's being said.


There's no story that helps the meaning of the words to "bypass the audience's critical minds."


So there's no value.


It's just bleh, bleh, bleh.

So how can you improve a lyric draft like the one I've used as an example above?


It's simple, you tell a story!


More specifically, ...

  • you choose one core universal human need you want the song to revolve around (and you set up that promise as soon as possible)
  • you dial in on the one specific problem the song's main character is dealing with
  • you use signaling words to make the relationship clear between the song's main character and the person they address
  • you show the contrast between the song's main character trying to solve their problem and the better place they want to get to = contrast between verses (journey there) and chorus (having arrived)
  • you include the time, the place, and at least one literal action that anchors the song's main character in that time/place (while the literal action is an expression of their micro strategy or their climax choice)
  • you tell a story to take the audience on a journey and create the necessary experience so your song's valuable message can 'bypass their critical minds to touch their hearts and change their worldview'.

So how could that look like regarding the example we used before?

(Verse 1)

In the silence of love, I search for peace

Trying to mend what's torn, to find release

Can you see how switching "night" with "love" sets up the core need of what the song will be about?


Letting the audience immediately know it's a love song?


The second line now has a better reference point.


By referring to "trying to mend what's torn," we think of someone's heart.


We now have a clearer picture in our minds. We already have more context!

Feels like I'm chasing shadows in an empty room

where we were supposed to dance as bride and groom

Now we know where the song's main character is (we can picture them in an empty ballroom), and we understand more about the gravity of the situation because they broke up when they were supposed to get married.


That creates a lot of empathy because we understand how much it must hurt to be left on such a special occasion that is meant to be one of the happiest days of someone's life.


And through starting the song with the breakup, you have the beginning of the story.


You could then include the turning point moment in another verse.


This moment throws the song's main character into a crisis, and they have to make a choice about how they will continue: Will they double-down on what they did before? Or move on from the past?


For example, the verse could have a turning point that refers to the old love showing up with someone new (for more dramatic effect, it could be in the very same room):

(Verse x)

Now you're here in this same old rollercoaster room

with someone to promise to keep your love true

And I'm standing frozen, what could I do?

This is how you tell a story.


Taking the audience on a journey through a particularly turbulent time in someone's life, where something happened that threw their life out of balance and led to another turning point event where they faced a crossroad moment ... an important choice.


And what they did (expressed by a literal action) shows the listener their internal decision expressed in an active choice.


And through that, the message you're trying to communicate... those empowering statements you wanted them to know... that's how they gain meaning.



Now, when you wonder HOW can you actually tell a story in a song so you can achieve this meaningful progression that leads to a valuable takeaway that truly impacts your listeners... then I have it already all mapped out for you.


Check out the Lyric Mastery Circle (for FREE), and you can explore the Lyric Mastery Success Path that is all about telling powerful stories in song lyrics!


See info below 👇

Storytelling in Songwriting Narrative Songwriting Online Course

The best way to improve is by getting feedback!

If you want to be confident in your lyrics before you record your song, you can now sign up below to get constructive, actionable feedback on your song lyrics. So you know what works and how you can do better so that you can hook, move, and impact your audience with your words.

Storytelling in Songwriting Checklist
  • STEP #1

Get Your FREE Copy.

So you can grab your listener's attention with your song's first line!

  • STEP #2

Discover the Power of Storytelling in Songwriting

Subscribe to my YouTube Channel for lyric breakdowns, songwriting tips, tutorials, discography studies, and songwriter battles 🥊.

Thanks for reading,

Melanie.


Stop Second-Guessing Your Lyrics

Get Real Feedback That Moves You Forward

Click below to get constructive, actionable feedback on your song lyrics. So you know what works and how you can do better so that you can hook, move, and impact your audience with your words.

Leave a Comment

© Copyright 2025 - LyricMastery by Melanie Naumann